Portugal was the second country to receive a bailout from the EU and IMF after its financial sector, much like Greeces, faced immanent collapse. Although the state lacked the resources to provide them with a full bailout, it invested billions in reestablishing the banks under new names so that they could resume trading. 0.2% for protestants). This types of inbreeding may show up as identical on meassures that average entire populations. Particular among these variations is the history of Northwestern Europe, which had unique in the world a long history of avoiding inbreeding. @simon For instance the guestimate map of inbreeding seems to not explain why Scandinavians are known for genetic disorders like Haemochromatosis and Huntingtons diseases. probably when gypsies arrived, only inbred community here Slavs settled 500 AD Many royal families share common ancestors and thus share a lot of the genetic pool. The countrys mounting difficulties contributed to the risks facing the euro, which was in danger of collapsing in 2012 and has still not been stabilized today. That group so happens to be the entire nation. Not sure but I think the European Jewish population was quite small in the thousands? so, i think its going to vary across europe. Also, its worth noting that historic rates of inbreeding are just one selective force among many (not the least of which being the effects of manorialism, of strong states, and of internal population replacement ala Gregory Clark/Ron Unz) which act on a population (which may act synergistically to produce the traits we see), and close analysis may not reveal a perfect association between modern clannishness and historical rates of inbreeding, perhaps due to the vagaries of other selective forces that have been acting on these populations. Furthermore, our Greek and Macedonian samples share much higher numbers of common ancestors with Albanian speakers than with other neighbors, possibly a result of historical migrations, or else perhaps smaller effects of the Slavic expansion in these populations. Slovenia is also similar in its high inbreeding and yet low corruption and high openness. However, one incongruity appears to be Italy, and to a lesser extent, Spain and Greece. While I dont have the exact answer re: inbreeding in Haiti, I did write a blog post on the D.R. balkan endogamy The Whitakers are British by descent and live in unkempt conditions. The north Atlantic islands economy collapsed during the financial crisis of 2008, as all three of its major banks went bust. With a per capita GNI of $3,540, Ukraine is the poorest country in Europe as of 2020. share. (please ignore my shortened comment, something with my WP password) I cant agree with some parts of the inbreedness map. maybe.) Italys economy has never recovered since, with it being the only country in the G7 not to have returned to output levels prior to the crisis. I mean that you find nothing but shicksas in every maternal line if you go back enough generations. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.Privacy Policy | Affiliate Disclosure. Communism is a massive shake to a national integrity and system of values. Marriages between royal dynasties have become less and less common in modern times. To learn about our use of cookies and how you can manage your cookie settings, please see our Cookie Policy. In 2013, the governor of the Japanese central bank warned that the extreme levels of debt were unsustainable. However, one incongruity appears to be Italy, and to a lesser extent, Spain and Greece. Im thinking a better measure of individualism/conformism would be the variation if views, attitudes, way of living etc. Those Who Can See: Chalk and cheese, Russia and Eastern Europe: . The development of the mining sector is raising hopes that the government will obtain increased revenues to cut debt levels. Razib Khan recently objected to HBD Chicks hypothesis based on genetic data reviewed by Peter Ralph and Graham Coop. fanTAStic post! A Guardian article published in 2013 noted that the number of women dying in childbirth had almost doubled since 1990, while the number of children completing primary school fell by over 25 percent. early and late medieval irish mating practices russians, eastern europeans, runs of homozygosity (roh), and inbreeding Indeed, this plot excellently follows the east-west divide that exists in Europe, and does an excellent job of catching the north-south divide as well. These are general ideas based on the evidence I have so far seen. @helvena: (The high immigrant populations in the ex-Soviet states are mostly Russians; those in Ireland are primarily from Britain. I hear they have civic clubs in Tokyo whose members go around cleaning public toilets. Keep in mind that Ashkenazi Jews are all descended from European shicksas. Ashkenazim are a relatively homogeneous group despite their settlement in different European countries for centuries. Low rate of marriage between 1st and 2nd cousins. HBD Fundamentals:On the evolution of modern advanced civilized peoples, Also see this brand new post at Staffans Personality Blog: The Clannish World of Organized Crime, Edit 3/13/14: See also big summary post on the hajnal line | hbd* chick, Your email address will not be published. These divisions have had great significance for the past and present of these countries and the countries they sired. Greece the most troubled country in Europe also has the worst lettering. I think you may have hit the nail on the head. So Montenegro and Albania are more inbred than Iceland? The reference population had an inbreeding value of 3.16 percent, while the whole had an inbreeding value of 2.17 percent. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. the swedes (and other scandinavians) are an interesting case because, although you guys starting outbreeding relatively late (i think) i.e. Many articles point out that in absolute, monetary terms, the United States has the highest level of debt, but it is also the largest economy so that is hardly surprising. A lot of this looks questionable, some looks based on bias/prejudice/preconceived ideas. Most distinct are the United Kingdom, Spain, Italy, and Germany (while Portugal is shown with a north-south gradient, Im not sure if one exists there). The volunteers were all individuals of European descent born between 1938 and 1967. This is an all-round excellent summary you put together here Jayman. I doubt the Soviets encouraged migration on the same scales as happened in the rest of Europe during the 1900s, but of course I could be wrong. It would be interesting to look into how inbreed Haiti is and compare that finding to Iceland and to the Dominican Republic espcially given Haitis history. As we can see, my map is in very good agreement with Ralphs and Coops data, particularly the pronounced divide between Western and Eastern Europe, as well as the regional variation across the British Isles. #3. civicness in spain by region, Italy: EDIT, 12/14/14: mating patterns in medieval norway. Also being so close to Korea, I knew hed have some of that. The investigation continues, @staffan Perhaps the conformism in Sweden is the results of everyone being more or less related rather than small groups being highly related?. There is evidence that heterozygosity is something that humans actively select for in mates, as well as selecting genetically dissimilar partners to produce more heterozygous offspring. According to the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, antidepressant use increased by nearly two and a half times from 2000 to 2020 in 18 European countries. Please see the links for historical information on marriage patterns. So Japan is really just one big clan. This is apparently centered somewhere around level 3. In 2012, Eritreas total debt was estimated at 118 percent of GDP. Pingback: Female Same-Sex Attraction Revisited | JayMan's Blog. Persian conquest in 600 BC In short, people in these countries expect their transgressions to be met with violent retribution. Later invasions in and out, so borders and people moved a lot Indeed, it would appear that way. That would seem to fit into HBD Chicks commonweal orientation. 63% of Sudanese are inbred. At the very least, the average Dutch person has historically moved around more than the average Russianthe Dutch had colonies in the US, Africa, India, and Indonesiawhereas the average Russian peasant was tied to their land and would have married locally. One of these was that it was somehow bad to marry your cousin. At least with the former two, a key problem is that we dont know what the regional breakdown would look like, and as my map makes clear, there should be a sharp regional divergence in historic inbreeding rates across these countries. Haiti is more inbred than the Dominican Republic for a few reasons: Haitis population is almost entirely African in origin theyve driven out most of the Americans and Europeans; while the Dominican population is a mix of African, European, and American. High inbreeding in Russia and low in Holland?hahahaha Southern Europe is generally considered to include Portugal, Spain, Italy, and Greece, parts of France, and countries in the southern part of Eastern Europe, like Croatia and Albania. As for the rest, yes, I agree. Dibang Baral, a sixth standard student didn't know anything . Reasons: very early history earliest human traces back to 1.4 millions of years, first pottery and jewelry back in 5000 BC The colors roughly correspond to HBD Chicks 11-point clannishness scale: if we take 1 as the least clannish and 10 as the most clannish, i would rate various groups as follows (these are todays judgements i reserve the right to alter these as i go forward and learn more about all of these populations! Pistorius, who assumed the role of the commander-in-chief of the Bundeswehr last month, said that the German armed forces as they are currently constituted would not be able to defend their homeland or protect NATO allies in Europe should they be forced into a direct war with a power such as Russia. Your email address will not be published. We have often used Europe and the Middle East as examples of this, because strong regional variations in historic rates of inbreeding exist in those places. The most significant cause for the high level of indebtedness for a number of countries was the bursting of the financial bubbles that emerged in the early 2000s, leaving the taxpayer responsible for bailing out the financial institutions which had made multi-billion losses. Also I bet the IQ data for Slovenia is wrong, if you check data for Italy, the region bordering Slovenia (Friuli) scores the highest in IQ (103). Im beginning to suspect that different kinds of inbreeding create different behaviors. Ralph and Coop looked at identity by descent (IBD), a measure of how many common ancestors individuals within a population share. 54% of Muslims in the United Arab Emirates and Qatar are inbred. They say one can come up with even stranger things if one goes back further. How do I view content? 67% of Saudi Arabians are inbred. more on consanguinity in england (and scotland) But that may not be so much of a problem. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page. How it got that way is not quite clear at this point. Brazil, Japan, India, and Israel are the most inbred country in the world Inbreeding statistics by state The U.S has a low inbreeding rate of about 0.1 to 0.2% only 700 words. As well, supporting the notion that some European countries possess distinct regional variation within them in how inbred their populations are, we have these pieces: For Britain (from traditional family systems in medieval britain and ireland | hbd* chick): And Spain (from here and here, respectively): Reinforcing the pattern we see across Europe and much of the world are the results of the Worlds Values Survey: The Northwestern European countries are in a group by themselves. my scandinavian history is more than a little fuzzy can never keep track of when the kalmar and other unions were! With more lunar missions than ever on the horizon, the European Space Agency wants to give the moon its own time zone. Anthropologists traditionally concentrate on small isolates within a country for the estimation of inbreeding. So maybe we should look at islanders. Figures for the remainder are (in %): Italy (78), Austria (73), France (65), Norway (56),. As for Greece, and perhaps Turkey, these countries have both seen many admixture events and population movements, which is perhaps responsible for the smaller IBD rates seen there. The frequency of first cousin marriages in Portugal may lie between 1 and 2 per cent. Historically, I dont think there was a lot of internal movement in Japan, due to a pretty dictatorial state, which would tend to increase inbreeding, but that same dictatorial state really cut down on violence. I get the feeling research is being cherry picked for articles/data supporting someones pet theses.. for instance, once the reformation happened, most of the newly minted protestant nations allowed cousin marriage again (because it isnt prohibited in the bible), but sweden did NOT. For example, these countries are known to have much higher rates of hydrocephalus, neural tube defects, and congenital heart defects. Y. Kleiman, DNA and Tradition (2004); E. Abel, Jewish Genetic Diseases (2001). absolutely! American populations are noteworthy for their extremely low inbreeding rates, with the mean frequency of first cousin marriages in the United States probably lower than 0.1 per cent. My granddaughters are half Dutch. There are a lot of birth defects. I for sure know that the high IBD rates in Albania and Kosovo are not due to inbreeding. The Middle East, Central South Asia and the Americas have the highest levels of inbred individuals. This may be the case in Finland & Japan, and might explain the interesting in-between characteristics these societies have. 3099067 1% for catholics in the region and ca. Fractionalization is the probability that two individuals drawn randomly from the country's groups are not from the same group (ethnic, religious, or whatever the criterion is). | murderbymedia2, Pingback: A study in inbreeding So I Moved to London, Pingback: Foundations of civilization London. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. Incest isnt revealed to outside parties so the parties involved arent prosecuted. but what about the english? Overall, the general pattern appears to be considerably longer history of outbreeding in Northwestern Europe and progressively shorter one as you move outward from there. Leviticus 18:7 to 18 and 20:11 to 21 are some of the prohibitions found there. Peter Frost described something similar. By the 1800s it was said that every royal in Europe was mentally ill. And certainly that every royal family was an inbred family. So the high IBD rates would probably much rather be attributed to the rapid growth rather than inbreeding. THANK YOU! #countries #maps #history #europe #africa #shorts #empire #stats #usa -----Join Disc. This map is a guestimate, and is not derived from direct measurements. you might also want to check all my other posts on the history of mating patterns in various other populations (see left-hand column toward the bottom of the page on my blog). The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. A small percentage of marriages in the US are between cousins. The Albanian language is a Indo-European language without other close relatives [53] that persisted through periods when neighboring languages were strongly influenced by Latin or Greek, suggesting an intriguing link between linguistic and genealogical history in this case., SOURCE: https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.1001555, Pingback: Everything the European peoples have ever lived for is being buried under a tidal wave of enemy sewage. I was hoping to get your impressions in particular. The state ofKentucky! By Antonia Leonard May 31, 2022 Data on inbreeding in several contemporary human populations are compared, showing the highest local rates of inbreeding to be in Brazil, Japan, India, and Israel. english individualism ii Those isolates, however, might not be . Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. oddly, many of my liberal race-is-a-social-construct friends advocate mixing all races together to achieve a beige standard presumably that would be the most outbred therefore their beige ideal may harbor the same (or worse) suicidal-to-humans tendency seen in (overly) well-outbred types perhaps the beige group would defer to different mammals:) The offspring of two siblings are about the same in age. JayMan, you have a real gift for (among other things) bringing together a treasure trove of pertinent links and maps on a topic into one succint post. I would add, as explanation, that if you have small groups of people which move around a lot and occasionally accept new members, the new members can add a great deal of genetic variety. But I guess these other diverse populations magically dont have genetic diseases but are yet still inbred, right? If you have some other information, please share it. Still, while all royals carried dangerous genes, most were born relatively healthy. More recently, policies pursued by the government to resolve the crisis have tended to push debt levels even higher. you decide whether or not ive been cherry-picking: inbreeding in sweden Pakistan and Israel having nuclear weapons is already bad enough. Inbreeding led to the demise of the Spanish royal dynasty. (F.R.B. These divisions (with some exceptions which soon Ill note) shouldnt be taken to be hard and fast. But not all inbreeding is the same. @Cryo . (good for you! Inbred places look like primitive cave markings. Japan leads the way in terms of its debt to GDP ratio, which was 226 percent in 2013. But it is one factor among many in shaping the selective forces acting upon a people. I disagree when it concerns Norway. Discussions are currently taking place in Europe about restructuring Greeces massive state debt, which has risen sharply since 2008. Annual visitors: 38. My guesses: Iceland is most inbred because the population is smaller. This week, the agency said space organizations around the world are considering how best to keep time on the Moon. Ethnic Russians,a roughly 50-50 genetic mix of finnic and slavonic nations are one of the least inbred nations of Europe.Holland on the other hand has one of the highest percentages. In short, the more IBD, the more genetically similar the population is. [extreme inbreeding] . (^_^). both diseases can, of course, get concentrated in inbred lineages, but the inbreeding does not cause either of them. The . However, it visualizes what areas we think are the most and least inbred, based on these regions histories and other pieces of evidence we have. I dont think White Americas conservative future will provoke Armageddon. Are blue eyes an indication of inbreeding? As said in the post, the guestimate isnt without basis in the evidence. They are inbred because of isolation, but not because they have preferentially mated with cousins. Analysts note, however, that it is extremely difficult to get full financial information about the country due to the secrecy of the government. I think of this as grainy inbreeding, meaning small groups of highly related individuals, and smooth inbreeding where everyone is moderately related. Inbreeding is the production of offspring from the mating or breeding of individuals or organisms that are closely related genetically. Alien perspectives cant hurt. Age: 34 (1819-1853) Birthplace: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. You do see the links in the post, yes? And one more thing- corruption map? However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. Europe, second smallest of the world's continents, composed of the westward-projecting peninsulas of Eurasia (the great landmass that it shares with Asia) and occupying nearly one-fifteenth of the world's total land area. Beyond 1,500 ya, the rates of IBD drop to levels typical for other populations in the eastern grouping., The highest levels of IBD sharing are found in the Albanian-speaking individuals (from Albania and Kosovo), an increase in common ancestry deriving from the last 1,500 years. While in 2013 the economy grew at just 2 percent, the debt burden rose by 10 percent. The Cavaliers (and even the Appalachians) are far less likely to hit the red button than some African or Asian despot. People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read. Second, although not made clear in the post (and perhaps in hindsight, it should be), when we say a population is inbred, we dont necessarily mean that the average fellow in this population is more related to one of his compatriots than people in another population. This is the real money question, We know arranged marriages between cousins was the norm until at least the late 1800s, It was common wisdom in the Jewish community that you dont marry for love you marry to create intelligent, competitive offspring, Very interesting how the elite media and Hollywood has pushed for years the so-called backwardness of inbreeding. Updated on March 2, 2023. That is also true for Macedonia and at some extent Northern Greece (excl. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. feuds, tournaments, and reproductive success in medieval germany (franconia), Spain: Though this map is an educated guess, it is based on several important pieces of evidence, which I will now review, starting with one the key pieces. ), The decline in violence across Europe during the past millennium, which was discussed by Steven Pinker in his bookThe Better Angels of Our Nature, (discussed here: violence around the world | hbd* chick). Even the budget is not usually released for public view. In total, government debt is estimated at 202 percent of GDP. They have a large (albeit, historically isolated) population, so perhaps that help to selection out clannishness? By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. clannish medieval ireland The latest available figure for state debt was in 2012, when it was 127.3 percent of economic output. But there was only a certain number of royal families out there. Perhaps the conformism in Sweden is the results of everyone being more or less related rather than small groups being highly related? Many Muslim countries have low murder rates but when people from these countries emigrate to more free countries they become very violent and account for a lot of the murders in their new countries. This correlates to the rates of civic involvement seen across these countries, also discussed by HBD Chick (here and here): EDIT: Also, HBD Chick has recently posted a table of ranking nations of their individualistic vs. collectivist tendencies, from Geert Hofstedes Dimensions. And indeed, perhaps this was the case. As HBD Chick discusses, the disappearance of references to Germanic kindreds (the Germanic version of the clan, see medieval germanic kindreds and the ditmarsians | hbd* chick and more on medieval germanic kindreds | hbd* chick) also follows this pattern: (In that post ibd rates and kindreds in germanic populations HBD Chick also examines the samples used in Ralphs and Coops analysis. Jan 16, 2015. Historically, I dont think there was a lot of internal movement in Japan, due to a pretty dictatorial state, which would tend to increase inbreeding, but that same dictatorial state really cut down on violence. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Bad drivers are a good indicator of a corrupt government Zimbabwe has been in arrears with the IMF for over 15 years and is currently ineligible to receive further funds until it pays outstanding bills. Ashkenazi Jews are not inbred 2 Gene Expression | DiscoverMagazine.com, In short, his analysis of the genetic data shows that Ashkenazi Jews are not more inbred than surrounding populations, which might fit with certain behaviors that they exhibit. There is a family from West Virginia called the Whitakers. Most distinct are the United Kingdom, Spain, Italy, and Germany (while Portugal is shown with a north-south gradient, I'm not sure if one exists there). cousin marriage or not) in sweden so far. Some of the countries with the highest rates of inbreeding include Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Lebanon, Egypt, and Israel. mating patterns, family types, and clannishness in twentieth century ireland HBD Chick and I will continue to work, with the hope of getting to bottom of what is going on, as all science aims to accomplish. Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine. 60% of Iraqis are inbred. These divisions have had great significance for the past and present of these countries and the countries they sired. I mean, if everyone loves gay people, thats not individualism. (^_^) (i will have to take a closer look at it during the week, though.). Read some history and genetics for a f* sake. Im beginning to wonder if the reason why I dont identify with liberals or conservatives might be that I am half and half, a mix of more inbred european stock (polish/Irish) with less inbred (English, German). Its actually the only study that uses an actual IQ test (!) Last warning] Top 10 - Inbreeding and Stillbirth Countries in the World 42,665 views Mar 22, 2015 294 Dislike Save sophie taylor 6.4K subscribers Notice Age-restricted video (based on Community Guidelines). document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Nice, cant see the first map though, maybe its my browser or something. @hbdchick Except they do since theyre recessive traits. exogamous marriage in medieval england 1000-1200 onwards. Brazil, Japan, India, and Israel have the highest local rates of inbreeding among contemporary humans. Did you know that with a free Taylor & Francis Online account you can gain access to the following benefits? Japan seems to still be the exception however. Just my 2 cents , By far the highest rates of IBD within any populations is found between Albanian speakersaround 90 ancestors from 0500 ya, and around 600 ancestors from 5001,500 ya (so high that we left them out of Figure 5; see Figure S12). Yours is an interesting question; perhaps differences in inbreeding/outbreeding may have some explanatory power re: differences between Dominicans and Haitians (and elsewhere in the Caribbean and Central/South America, areas that Im either actively researching or will research in due time). Oh, my family (my brother did himself) came out part Japanese on our fathers side and this is just going back 500 years. ), but in nineteenth century alsace-lorraine, the cousin marriage rate for jews was only 2.3% (compared to ca. 5 March, 2023 12:15 am IST. early modern and modern clannish ireland I dont mean that you will find a shicksa in every family tree. Is that Ottoman influence, or what? The price rises began around the year 2000, when the government backed a program of seizing land from white landowners and handing it to small-scale black farmers. Inbreeding can lead to a higher risk of genetic problems or chromosomal abnormalities in a child, as the genes that control traits may be the same in both parents, leading to passing down the same genetic trait. While the new Syriza government won elections last month with the. Our family has been researching ourselves for decades because were very diverse and when I married my husband I made it much more diverse. In most of the United States, incest is against the law. 1tn), or 13. The within-family coefficient of relationship are higher in these inbred populations (or at least were in the not to distant past, since many of these formerly inbreeding populations have since switched to marriage outside the family). In 2012, they agreed to a restructuring package supposedly to make repayment more manageable, cutting the ratio to 95 percent. Italy: Sardinia is VERY inbred [Corsica also]. more on albanians, Scandinavia: Photo: Getty Images. Id be remiss to not mention the effect of geography, climate, and topography on this (from Wikipedia): Mountains may contribute to inbreeding by making both farming and long-range travel difficult (favoring a pastoral way of life) see the flatlanders vs. the mountain people | hbd* chick.