Hello. can you please tell me the reason why it has been rejected, so that i can correct it and resubmit it. Make sure to share any further questions in the comments. MDPI Submission Process: Your Questions Answered, Getting Involved with the Editorial Process Q&A, How to Advance as an Early Career Researcher, Challenges and Opportunities: Early Career Researchers, How to Reduce Stress Whilst Waiting for Publication, MDPIs Policy Regarding Corrections and Retractions. Every MPDI manuscript is converted into different formats, ready for publication. Please get in touch with the journals Editorial Office, and they will update this for you. Decision pending for more than 15 days - Academia Stack Exchange As part of this, the Editorial Office asks reviewers if they want to disclose their identity. Hello Katherine. Thank you very much for your comment. Hi As your paper is still being processed, you can easily withdraw and re-submit the paper. If you need more details about your case, in particular, the assistant editor assigned to your manuscript can help with that. Furthermore, the reviewers then have 1-2 weeks to provide their comments. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Reviewer 1 I have submitted manuscript to Animals on 1st of September and I received reject and encourage resubmittion. Yes, you can reach out to the Editorial Office of Polymers and theyll be able to inform you as to why there might have been a delay. English correction done = The paper has been edited for English, which takes about 24 hours. This stage usually takes 1-2 working days. Thank you for getting in touch. Hi Islam. Is the SI guest editor (SI GE) the one who decides to proceed with the evaluation of the paper with a peer review or it is a decision that is being made without the involvement of the GE (by the managing editor or the MDPI staff)? MDPI prides itself on the high speed and flexibility of its publication. The next status will be Revised version review, when reviewers will have their second look. Or should we just wait? Does it mean Rejection? Your paper is actually going through an open peer review. If you find yourself waiting for more than a week, its best to contact the Assistant Editor for an update. Please get in touch with the editor assigned to your manuscript about this issue. You should review the feedback on SuSy. Id encourage you to get in touch with the Editorial Office if its been five working days without an update. The status of paper is pending decision for 33 days. This usually takes 2-3 weeks in total. Hello Katherine Bosworth! Traditional journals nowadays take really long time to review, while MDPI can guarantee the speed. Because today is the 44th day after my first submission date and the status of my article is still unchanged. Yes, thats correct. I submitted an article to microorganisms. I am worried if the deadline is not met. I also email to editorial office but they dont reply to me. Since the date of submission, the manuscript is still under the Review status. You can find out more about our peer review process, pre-check and other policy requirements here: https://www.mdpi.com/editorial_process. Please check your junk and spam folders. Check out our article on manuscript statuses for more information. Then we revised it and submitted it on 13th of November. Most of our journals suggest 5 days for minor revisions and 1014 days for major revisions. I have replied to reviewers comments for the second time today. If you submit without using an MDPI template, the Assistant Editor will help you with the layout during paper processing. This is because the average waiver rate across all MDPI journals was 35%. From sharing the latest MDPI blog news, to showcasing our most popular articles, the newsletters will keep you in the loop with everything good going on in the science world. Check out this article on MDPIs name change policy for more information about how you can update the authors of your manuscript. I am so sorry that you have been waiting so long. Please could you get in touch with the Sustainability Editorial Office for further information? ? Please do get back in touch if you find yourself waiting any longer than this. Contributions should be listed during the submission process and are also part of the journal template. It usually takes 12 days. . Plz, reply me. They will be able to advise you on your specific case. You may include others ideas and words, as long as you quote and reference them appropriately. Moreover, it significantly contributes to knowledge and guides dentists to evidence based recommendations in the practice. What Does My MDPI Manuscript Status Mean? However, the average net cost to authors across all journals was CHF 1258 per paper. Shouldnt the editor have allowed for pending minor or major revisions? I submitted my article on January 4, 2023, with the manuscript ID of polymers-2173405 on journal polymers . Thanks a lot. The editor really supports our effort as authors. Now its more than 21 days. This is highly unusual and can likely be quickly resolved. If youre having trouble accessing this, please feel free to contact the journals Editorial Office. Average duration of "Pending Decision"? - ResearchGate What does it means? It will include instructions and insight related to next steps. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); 2023, MDPI Blog is a solution provided by MDPI AG. Pending major or minor revisions = Author revisions are in progress. However, as this is something youre concerned about, you can contact the Editorial Office directly. May I know why is it so? MDPI joined CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) early on in the initiatives launch. If you have prepaid, MDPI will send a refund on request. Unfortunately, as soon as the manuscript is accepted for submission, the authors cannot be changed. However, there is no guarantee that your work will be accepted for publication. Our authors publications in English have enabled broad international readership, with more than 14 million MDPI webpage views monthly in 2020. What does it mean. However, if your paper has already been published, it will have to remain in open review. Many apologies for the delay. This manuscript status indicates that a paper has been pre-checked and is now being peer-reviewed. Across all Wolters Kluwer journals, the average . Make sure to review the rejection feedback in SuSy and apply it to your manuscript, if applicable. I think it is not fear that we has pass the blind review pass and now after acceptance the managing editor decided that they are not accepting our changes regarding author addition. We tried to enquire the same from assistant editor, section managing editor and Cells editorial office but did not get any response. All the editorial, production, and invoicing steps are managed using MDPIs SuSy and are performed by in-house employees, largely using software created and maintained by MDPI. Yes. MDPI journals all have a stringent peer review process to ensure the novelty and scientific accuracy of manuscripts. I hope we can receive a detailed peer review report. I have published a few papers in Sustainabiltiy, and had several rejected. Authors retain the rights to their published content. MDPIpending decisionPending editor decision. We find the automatic answer given to authors after rejected by editor considerably vague and in contradiction with the San Francisco Declaration, which MDPI signed on 2012 with this motto: We aim to publish all manuscripts that are scientifically correct, and do not artificially increase journal rejection rates, allowing the reader community at large to define impact. If this is correct, then what is rejection based on novelty and general significance after rejection by the editor? Im going to chase this up on your behalf. However, we may ask you to withdraw your paper if a round of revisions will take longer than a month. For updates related to your article, please contact the editorial office of the journal that you submitted to. I was asked to review for an MDPI journal and realized while requesting to extend the deadline for my review that the editor at MDPI intended to send review requests to several reviewers, to gather enough reviews to make a decision on the basis of the first 2-3 he received. Please could you reach out to the journals Editorial Office? The first round of reviews usually takes around two to three weeks. The reviewing stage is important to journal integrity. Last decision: Reject Reviewer 3 Ole Jonny Klakegg Major (Report sent on 13 October 2020) Last decision: Reconsider after major revision. Take a look at our article on manuscript status information. The IOAP entitles authors to a 10% discount on APCs. I went through the portal today and saw that the editors decision is to ask for additional review I am confused what does it mean. Pending review = The paper is due to be pre-checked. You can find the median publishing pipeline times for each journal in the section Rapid Publication on the journals webpage. Please I have only two question I really appreciate if I got the answer: 1- Did my status changed to Pending major or miner decision before that I dont know because I didnt check my status This status means that our team of English editors are reviewing your manuscript for grammar, spelling, and MDPI house style. What does it mean? How can we know if something went wrong with our paper? This stage usually takes about 1-5 working days. I havent checked my status for two weeks since it was Under Review. This depends on the nature of the update. Dear Ms. Bosworth, You can find this information on MDPIs SuSy platform. Is a long "Ready for Decision" status a bad sign? | Editage Insights Upon completion of the production steps, the article will be available online. can I ask for payment extension of the apc? Can I cancel the request for an update of the published paper? Hi Rob. Yes, I understand that the reviewers and editors are too busy during this time, but I appreciate a response as soon as possible so I can make a decision about my paper. Is it possible to do edits after the publication extremely necessary one, for example a mistake in formula on which the results are based? In open peer review, the reviews are published online when the manuscript is. Hope this helps. Thanks for reaching out. If possible, could you help to reach editorial office on my behalf. What does it mean? The author also gives their consent individually via email. Review . pending editor decision mdpi how long - mathtutorweeks.com How long does this process take to complete? Please how much similarity is acceptable to MDPI energies? Because we have been contacting the SI GE and he showed substantial interest in our paper (even offered us off on the APC), but the paper did not successfully go through the pending review stage. The papers got desk rejections and the same work is not accepted by IEEE Q1 journals. Still, it is under review. Im sorry that youve been waiting longer than expected. Hopefully, you will get a decision very soon. Recently however, one was rejected that I believe is a good paper. After submitting the revised version and getting back the 3 reviewers comments (Round 2), the current status is now pending decision since 10 days. It could be because the paper does not fit into the scope of the journal, or because the reviewers felt the findings were incomplete, for example. If youre struggling with this, you can reach out to the Academic Editor assigned to your paper, who can add the vouchers before the paper is accepted. To find out more, check out our interview with MDPI English editors. The Assistant Editor aims to find reviewers within the first week of sending out invitations. Access it here: https://susy.mdpi.com/, Hello! I would like to inquire about the status of my manuscript that has been under review since the 21st of November 2022 [Cells] Manuscript ID: cells-2079368. Publishing times also differ depending on the journal. Congrats! But if go through the link the editorial decision is showing rejected and redeclined submission. This process usually takes 1-2 working days. However, this can sometimes take longer and is dependent on the availability of reviewers. Hi Navdeep, thanks for your comment. I will get in touch with Energies on your behalf. Of course, authors can track the status of their paper. The deadline would be midnight at the end of that day. Yet, our paper has been declined for publication with no resubmission. Sorry that this is taking a bit longer than expected. I have contacted the Data Editorial Office and I will keep you updated. Reviewers then have up to two weeks to return their comments, but reviewers may request more time. However, authors should consider in advance whether they have sufficient funds to cover the APC. Reasons added to the comment section by the editor was that the paper isnt ready for publication. Four reviewers gave good reviews and recommended the manuscript for publication. As you have been waiting for more than a week, please could you reach out to the Assistant Editor of your manuscript? Under review = The paper is being peer-reviewed. You can find more information about MDPI manuscript statuses in our handy blog article. Hi, Hi, I submitted my manuscript 29, July. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. could you provide me information that when that status will be updated? Hello, We submitted a manuscript to applied science but it we made a mistake by uploading the wrong version. They will be able to advise on any waivers and/or discounts available to you. This form applies to manuscripts that have already been published. May I know what the possible reason for the delay is? Hi Katherine We hope that this breakdown helped you to understand your manuscript status. The Assistant Editor will also ensure that reports are collected as agreed and will inform authors if any delays are expected. Please accept the editors changes before updating the manuscript. Professor, Moataz Elgezawi. We have reached out to the editorial office on your behalf and you should hear back from them soon. This is a mandatory step with no additional fee. how can I find my submitted paper reviewers emails? Whether my work is it Good or Bad? You can also check out one of our other articles to find out more about what your manuscript status means. If youre still waiting after a week, please could you get in touch with the Editorial Office? If your paper is still being processed (i.e., in one of the many processing stages such as Pending review or Pending editor decision), then you can contact the journals Editorial Office. I want to submit the manuscript to Social Science. Hi As an author, this manuscript status means that its time to review your manuscript and edit it using the comments provided. Hi Mubasharmubashar. I have contacted you privately about this matter; please check your spam and junk folders. You can find out about the journals scope in the Aims & Scope section, which can be accessed via the journal menu, or by searching for individual Special Issue webpages. Under review = The paper is being peer-reviewed. Is it possible to have a waiver from publication fees when I got the acceptance letter. This status also applies to second review rounds (revised version reviews). But not publishing online yet. If you cannot return the edited manuscript and/or responses within the agreed time, you can get in touch with the Assistant Editor, who may be able to grant you an extension. . You can simply email them back, in the same thread where they provided you with the first proofreading. You can get in touch with the editor assigned to your manuscript for specific details. after this, the editor says if you insist to add these authors then you should withdraw the paper. For example, if the document was originally uploaded in LaTeX format, can it then be uploaded in Word format?. can you please give me the exast answer. Once your paper has been accepted for publication, you cannot add or remove authors. As you know we cannot add/remove any author directly, so I have submit the authorship change form. Our paper has a status Pending editor decision for 12 days now (which is quite unusuall for Agronomy) and assigned editor does not reply to our e-mails asking about the status of our paper. It is a perfect fit with an open SI. can you please tell about this? Were conducting an investigation into how this happened. It will be published online within 24 hours. pending editor decisionpeer revieweditorial memberfinal decisionmdpi. This does depend on their schedules. I am planning to submit my article to the special issue of Vaccines. Is it possible to request for a second authors proof? As long as you have implemented this advice, theres no reason why your manuscript should not be accepted. We are assuming that MDPI is like a money machine nowadays and only or mostly accepted paper without the vouchers code. Hi, However, the editors decision was reject and decline submission. If I want to withdraw it, Can I refund my money? I revised the manuscript according to all comments and recommendations from the reviewers reports. Author proofreading resubmitted = Authors have resubmitted the latest version of their paper, and the Assistant Editor will accept changes and double-check that everything is correct before paper publication. Is the review process at MDPI fair to reviewers? [duplicate] Should I email the Assistant Editor about it? Click Editorial Office in the left-hand navigation bar. Furthermore, it is possible to update this down the line, so dont worry. The reviewers are chosen for their expertise by the Academic Editor and Assistant Editor. Please provide the reason for your withdrawal request. What is the meaning of pending review? - Rampfesthudson.com They will advise you of the decision and any action that you need to take. What is the procedure? As an author, you will receive email updates when you need to take action. As part of our service, an in-house Assistant Editor is assigned to each manuscript. I want to ask what if the different between abstract submission deadline and manuscript submission deadline ? Many thanks for the comment. What does it mean? MDPI | Information for Editors We have submitted our manuscript to Cancers and got major revision. I have submit my paper Id (sustainability-1826830) to sustainability. If you find yourself waiting for more than a week, it's best to contact the Assistant Editor for an update. They usually have a busy schedule. MDPI Pending editor decision . Other versions of your manuscript, including HTML, will soon follow. The Pending review stage usually takes about five working days maximum. can I ask to remove my name from the article authors list, before the manuscript is accepted? This year, we consistently provided discounts of 10% or more to authors affiliated with our institutional partners or reviewer vouchers. Hi everyone Ive submitted my paper long time ago its been two years years now since my status remains under review, what should I do at this moment Ive been trying sending an enquiries but there was know response. How long does it take to know the acceptance? Is there any expedited process, this means extra charge. The manuscript will be linked to the previous submission in SuSy. In many MDPI journals, Academic Editors who have made the acceptance decision for a manuscript, after full peer-review, have the option to include their name and role as the Academic Editor on the published manuscript. We have been waiting for over five days. Hi Ivana. Assistant Editors also communicate with reviewers and Academic Editors to see if they can recommend a colleague who would make a good reviewer. However, if this is related to an error in your formula, then take a look at this detailed policy regarding corrections and retractions. This is the second paper that I published in sustainability. Apologies for the delay. However, please note that this is dependent on the Academic Editors workload. Syracuse Haulers Schedule 2022 Rental Properties That Accept Evictions Venture Capital Portland, Oregon Amtrak Charger Locomotive Provo Daily Herald Local News Physical Education Unit Plan Comments are closed. I have a concern regarding MDPi policies. We submitted the manuscript entitled, A Systematic Review of Deep Knowledge Graph-based Recommender Systems, with focus on Explainable Embeddings on 2022-03-22, with manuscript ID: data-1670544. How long is MDPI under review? Once they are satisfied with the improvements, your paper will move to the next stage in the publication process. HTML, EPUB, and PDF versions are automatically generated. Please note that, if there are reviewer recommendations that have not been sufficiently addressed after two rounds of revisions, rejections or resubmissions may be warranted. After I typed Please see in the attachment, I happened to click the submit button. what is the chance for publication ? What is your experience as reviewer of MDPI and Applied - ResearchGate Hi Prof. Mallikarjuna, thank you for the comment. I can see the reviewer report is not very encouraging. special issue 12 1 17 -> 2 17 minor revision ( . If the paper was rejected because it did not fall within the scope of the Special Issue, then you can resubmit to a Special Issue that is more fitting. now its showing pending editor decision, which much time it will take to give decision? Please help me out of this situation. This is your very last chance to edit the paper. Here is a short video on manuscript status in Editorial Manager, and some additional articles on the manuscript submission process. I submitted my manuscript to the journal of Materials (materials-2126601) on December 13th. However, it can take slightly longer in some circumstances. But one reviewer gave -ve report. Your work will be read and rated by a few academics from your field. Around 12 business days. Various Dialect Groups on 2022-04-27, with manuscript ID: histories-1697518. The status for my sustainability-1961792 is showing Pending editor decision since 3rd Nov 2022. PDF Content Will the reviewer again make comments (which will take 3 more days) or it will directly go for editors decision? I already submitted our manuscript and it was under review. This means you need to submit your manuscript before or on the date outlined on the Special Issue webpage. Pending decision This manuscript status means that the Academic Editor is assessing the peer review process. However, we will allow extra time if you need it. As youve been waiting for more than a week, you can contact the Assistant Editor for an update. Good morning! How can we change or update the uploaded version? If I submitted an article in mdpi and 3 reviewers review the manuscript. Hi, good morning! My paper has accepted for publishing. Layout editing, as well as a plagiarism check, are offered at a fixed price. . Apologies that you have been waiting so long. If they were planning to not accept my changes. Thats an easy mistake to make. Can we publish an erratum correcting it? I ask this issue because I am not able to find a way during the submission process. I submitted a manuscript on the 3rd of June and I am yet to get any response as the paper is still under review.however when going through the manuscript portal yesterday I saw all the reviewers report commending the manuscript with little corrections. Regarding the significance, our survey is very important for dentists to find out shortages and limitations of Thiet practice and try to correct and improve. You can certainly reach out to the Managing Editor and inform them of this issue. Take a look at the article What Does My MDPI Manuscript Status Mean? for further information about manuscript statuses. I have a quary that during Proofread i have done a mistake can I submit it again.if possible then what should be the process. I recommend contacting the Assistant Editor about this issue. The status is under review. Our online submission system, SuSy (https://susy.mdpi.com/), should automatically detect any vouchers associated with your account. Please can you tell me when my paper will be indexed in Scopus and Web of Science. This is my first publishing experience and the third submission (MDPI) for my article. Not to worry. Here are answers to some of the questions that we are asked most often about the submission process, along with a video explaining in detail how to upload your manuscript. Thanks for being so patient. However, this all depends on the time frame in which the reviewers respond.